CertCities.com -- The Ultimate Site for Certified IT Professionals
Register today for a Free Sponsored Tech Library Webcast and you could WIN! Share share | bookmark | e-mail
  Microsoft®
  Cisco®
  Security
  Oracle®
  A+/Network+"
  Linux/Unix
  More Certs
  Newsletters
  Salary Surveys
  Forums
  News
  Exam Reviews
  Tips
  Columns
  Features
  PopQuiz
  RSS Feeds
  Press Releases
  Contributors
  About Us
  Search
 

Advanced Search
  Free Newsletter
  Sign-up for the #1 Weekly IT
Certification News
and Advice.
Subscribe to CertCities.com Free Weekly E-mail Newsletter
CertCities.com

See What's New on
Redmondmag.com!

Cover Story: IE8: Behind the 8 Ball

Tech-Ed: Let's (Third) Party!

A Secure Leap into the Cloud

Windows Mobile's New Moves

SQL Speed Secrets


CertCities.com
Let us know what you
think! E-mail us at:



 
 
...Home ... Editorial ... Columns ..Column Story Saturday: April 5, 2014


 Dulaney on Certs  
Emmett Dulaney
Emmett Dulaney


 Why Not Allow Open-Book Exams?
Plus, the search is on for CompTIA advisory committee members.
by Emmett Dulaney  
9/19/2007 -- For the life of me, I can't understand why open-book exams aren't allowed by any of the major vendors for introductory-level certification tests. Vendors go to great lengths to make sure that their testing environments are absolutely nothing like the real world.

A significant factor in problem-solving is knowing how to approach the problem. In the real world, would you want an administrator who tackled every problem with minutiae memorized from texts that were written when the operating system first came out? Or, would you want one who yanked down a reference tome, turned to knowledge bases, posted on forums and -- yes, every now and again -- resorted to Google?

Well over a dozen years ago, the NetWare track included an exam on service and support that required test takers to find solutions to certain problems using the online tools that came with a Novell subscription. Yes, it did require you to subscribe to expensive Novell services in order to know how to approach the exam (thank you, marketing department), but it also created an environment in which you were able to look up what you didn't know (thank you, technology department).

As long as the exams are timed and candidates aren't spending hours finding the solution to a simple problem, why shouldn't the exam environment be more like the workplace? Allow candidates to bring in their reference books, pop open a browser and access the resources they would normally turn to on a regular basis.

CompTIA Seeking Advisory Committee Members
CompTIA is seeking individuals who are interested in joining Certification Advisory Committees (CACs) to help with the direction of several certifications.

Committee members are currently being sought for Linux+, Project+ and Server+ certifications. Those interested are required to have at least three years of experience in their area of interest and be employed at companies in good standing as CompTIA corporate members.

Committee members generally participate in a quarterly conference call and attend an annual meeting.


Emmett Dulaney is the author of several books on Linux, Unix and certification. He can be reached at .

 


More articles by Emmett Dulaney:

-- advertisement --


There are 24 CertCities.com user Comments for “Why Not Allow Open-Book Exams?”
Page 1 of 3
9/19/07: Anonymous says: Open book exams? That is the dumbest thing I have ever heard for IT certification. I would rather have someone who memorizes stuff in a book when they study as oposed to someone who looked the answers up to pass an exam.
9/20/07: Grover from Cincinnati says: Finally, someone who wants the test to reflect the real world. I have been in the business for over 20 years, and I still have my "little blue book" that contains a list of 'where to find the answers. There is too much and it changes too fast to even start to keep all the information in my head. There are the things that are done on a regular basis that I have learned by doing them repeatedly, but the things that are done once a month or even twice a month, 'I go to the book'. To not do so, and risk making a mess is unacceptable. Other than squeezing a few more dollars out of the test taker, the Novel test using the online resources is the best idea. The MS test I have taken, my comments have been that they are based on a 'sterile' MS environment, and unrealistic parameters.
10/3/07: Ted from Baltimore says: To me, whether or not an exam ought to be open-book is a matter of the complexity of the exam. For more fundamental exams (Sun's SCJP, Zend's ZCE for PHP)... I do fully expect candidates with that certification to have basics memorized - if it's something that is the root of what you're supposed to know to have the credential, then you ought to not have to look it up. For more complicated tasks (think system administration or specialized language skillsets), I think that an open-book (either fully or with vendor-supplied materials) is appropriate.
8/28/09: Anonymous says: I fear these certs are sterilizing the IT world. Most of the great techs I know would not pass these subjective tests because their knowledge is based on practical solutions. I like how companies brag about thinking outside the box when these tests keep people inside the box. There is a problem when things are memorized, they are soon forgotten or set in stone. Example: when XP came out with some enhanced dos commands you still see people use call statements to handle the variable expansion problem. Well hello, if you learned how to research instead of memorize you would be using the more efficent setlocal switch to enable delayed expansion. Even on the linux side there are enhancements to BASH that the memorizers negate to use.
7/1/13: michael kors factory outlet from [email protected] says: ths michael kors factory outlet http://www.michaelkorsioutlet.org/
7/1/13: louis vuitton outlet online from [email protected] says: nice articles louis vuitton outlet online http://www.louisvuittonttoutlet.com
7/5/13: christianlouboutinoutleta.com from [email protected] says: nice articles christianlouboutinoutleta.com http://www.christianlouboutinoutleta.com
7/12/13: cheap nfl jerseys from afaftgsagfgaf*@gmail says: [email protected] cheap nfl jerseys http://nesyb.org/us.html
7/13/13: fake oaklyes outlet from afaftgsgh*@gmail.com says: There is nothing touches our imagination so much as a beautiful woman in a plain dress. -Joseph Addison fake oaklyes outlet http://www.houdeblog.com/fakeoakleys/
7/18/13: fake oaklyes outlet from afatgasf*@gmail.com says: I have study a few of the blogposts on your blog now, and I truly like your style of blogging. I bookmarked it to my favorites internet site list and will be checking back soon. Pls visit my internet site too and let me know your opinion. fake oaklyes outlet http://www.houdeblog.com/fakeoakleys/
First Page   Next Page   Last Page
Your comment about: “Why Not Allow Open-Book Exams?”
Name: (optional)
Location: (optional)
E-mail Address: (optional)
Comment:
   

-- advertisement (story continued below) --

top